A growing number of large 401(k) plans are adding a new kind of option: convert part of your balance into guaranteed monthly income without leaving the plan at all. J.P. Morgan recently expanded this kind of access inside its Retirement Link platform, and other major recordkeepers have been adding similar features.
If your plan added this and you're close to retirement, you now have a real decision in front of you: take the in-plan option, roll everything to an IRA and shop for your own annuity, or leave the balance as it is. The right call depends on terms most summary plan descriptions never explain clearly.
Decision
Describe where you stand with your plan right now
Pick the description that fits your situation.
Find Out What Your Plan Actually Offers
Plans describe this benefit differently. Some call it an in-plan annuity, some build it into a target-date fund as a built-in income feature, and some only offer it once you reach a certain age or balance. None of that is obvious from your quarterly statement alone.
Start with your plan's summary plan description and your HR or plan administrator, not a sales pitch from an insurer's representative. The questions below apply no matter what the feature is called.
If you're weighing an annuity outside the plan too, Questions to Ask Before You Buy a Retirement Annuity covers the open-market side of that same decision.
Weigh the Guarantee Against the Lock-In
A guarantee is only as good as the terms behind it. Before you move any part of your balance into an in-plan income option, find out exactly what you're trading for that guarantee, not just the monthly number on a projection sheet.
This matters most once you're actually taking income, not while you're still deciding. Ask what happens to a surviving spouse, what happens if you need the money faster than the contract allows, and what the ongoing fee looks like compared to the fund it replaced.
Keep legal questions focused on deadlines and next steps.
Build my listClose tool
Keep legal aid and paperwork meetings focused on deadlines, documents, and next actions.
Checklist
Ask HR or your plan administrator these first
Get the plain-language version before you read any marketing material.
0 of 3 done.
Checklist
Confirm whether this even applies to you
Do these first if you're not sure your plan offers anything like this.
0 of 3 done.
Timeline
Compare before you move anything
Each step narrows the decision instead of resting on one number.
Fees, surrender terms, and survivor options, from your plan administrator, not a projection screen.
Ask an outside annuity provider for the same categories: fee, survivor benefit, and access to a lump sum.
A guarantee is only as strong as the insurer's own financial strength rating, on either side of the comparison.
Ask whether a rollover or an in-plan election can be unwound later if your plans change.
Checklist
Confirm your protection now, not during a plan change
Ask these while the option is still active, so you're not guessing later.
0 of 3 done.
Save what you confirmed here before you commit any part of your balance.
If You're Comparing a Rollover Instead
Rolling the balance to an IRA and buying your own annuity gives you more choice of insurer and contract type. It also means leaving behind any safe-harbor protections the plan sponsor already did on your behalf when it picked and vetted the in-plan option.
Work through the comparison in order instead of comparing a single number from each side. A bigger projected monthly payment on one quote doesn't tell you much if the contracts behind it aren't comparable.
What Changes If Your Plan Drops the Option
Plans sometimes remove an investment option, including an in-plan annuity, when they switch recordkeepers or renegotiate contracts. Find out now what happens to your guarantee if that happens later, not after you get a letter about it.
Federal rules have expanded how these contracts can move with you instead of being cashed out against your wishes when a plan changes. Whether that protection applies to your specific plan and contract is still something only your plan administrator can confirm.
Common questions
What is an in-plan lifetime income option in a 401(k)?
It's a feature some 401(k) plans now offer that lets you convert part of your balance into guaranteed monthly payments for life without rolling the money out of the plan. It can take the form of a separate annuity purchase or a guarantee built into a fund you already hold, and the exact structure varies by plan.
Is an in-plan annuity the same as buying my own annuity after a rollover?
No. An in-plan option comes with insurers and terms your plan sponsor already selected and is required to vet on your behalf. Rolling over to buy your own annuity gives you more choice of insurer and contract type, but you lose that built-in vetting and take on the comparison yourself.
What happens to my in-plan annuity if I change jobs or my plan drops the option?
Federal rules have expanded how these contracts can move with you to another employer plan or an IRA instead of being cashed out, but whether that protection applies to your specific contract is something only your plan administrator can confirm. Ask now, while the option is active, rather than after you get a change notice.
What fees should I ask about before choosing an in-plan income option?
Ask for the annual fee on the income guarantee itself, separate from the regular expense ratio of the fund it's attached to, along with the fee or penalty for accessing a lump sum once you've started taking the guaranteed income. Get the numbers in writing rather than relying on a verbal summary.
