Losing a doctor you've trusted for years is its own small grief, even when the reason is ordinary: retirement, a closed practice, or a plan that no longer includes them. The part that catches people off guard is what comes next. A Medicare card doesn't automatically hand you a replacement, and not every doctor who shows up in a search actually takes new patients on your plan.
The process is workable once you know the order to do things in: search with the right tool, confirm the practice is actually open to you, then move your records before the first visit. Here's how to do each step without losing weeks to dead ends.
Decision
Tell us why you're looking
Pick the situation that matches yours right now.
Start With Medicare's Own Doctor Finder
Skip the general search engines. If you have Original Medicare, use Medicare's Care Compare tool to search by location, specialty, or a doctor's name, and check whether each listing accepts Medicare assignment. If you have a Medicare Advantage plan, your plan's own provider directory is the more accurate source, since it reflects that plan's specific network rather than Medicare in general.
Either way, call the practice directly before you get attached to a name. Online directories lag behind real staffing changes more often than people expect.
If a Medicare Advantage network change is what sent you here, read Medicare Advantage Insurer Exit: What to Check for what else to look at before your next enrollment decision.
Confirm They're Actually Taking New Medicare Patients
A directory listing is not a guarantee. Call each practice and ask plainly whether they're accepting new Medicare patients, not new patients in general. Some practices cap their Medicare patient count separately from their overall patient count.
This is also when to ask about the doctor's Medicare status. A participating provider accepts Medicare's approved rate as full payment. A non-participating provider can charge up to 15% more than that rate for the same visit. An opted-out provider doesn't take Medicare at all and would require a private contract, which is rare for primary care but worth ruling out with one question.
Walk into your visit ready to cover what changed.
Start my checklistClose tool
Collect recent changes and your main goal before an annual or follow-up visit.
Checklist
If your doctor is retiring or closing the practice
A closing practice usually knows this is coming and can help.
0 of 3 done.
Checklist
Build a short list before you call anyone
A list of three keeps you from over-committing to the first name you find.
0 of 3 done.
Checklist
Ask these four questions on the first call
Keep a note of the answers so you can compare practices later.
0 of 4 done.
Timeline
Get your records moving on a real schedule
Starting this the same week you pick a new practice keeps the first visit from starting blind.
Sign a records release with your old provider and name the new practice as the recipient.
Call the new practice and ask whether the records arrived and whether anything looks missing.
Keep your own copy of medication lists and recent test results in case the transfer is still catching up.
Save your search notes and records checklist so nothing gets lost between calls.
Move Your Medical Records Before You Go
Under federal privacy rules, you have the right to a copy of your medical records, and your old provider generally has up to 30 days to send them, sometimes another 30 days if they notify you of the delay in writing. Ask for records well before your first appointment with someone new, not the week of.
A reasonable, cost-based copying fee is allowed, but the request itself should be simple: a signed release form, sent to the old office in writing, naming the new practice as the recipient if you want them sent directly.
